As college football evolves, QB transfer moves are becoming the most vital part of the sport
- - As college football evolves, QB transfer moves are becoming the most vital part of the sport
Dan Wolken January 18, 2026 at 2:46 AM
0
MIAMI BEACH, Fla. — Whether you like it or not, here’s the new economic reality of college football: If you’re an in-demand transfer quarterback, that job will be roughly as lucrative over the next year as being the No. 12 pick in the NFL Draft, the No. 15 pick in the NBA Draft, the 30th-ranked golfer on the PGA Tour and the No. 10 men’s tennis player in the world.
As we’ve watched the transfer portal over the past two weeks and heard the reported numbers attached to those transactions, it doesn’t always feel real. Four million here, five million there. It seems like Monopoly money.
For a college quarterback? Someone who may never throw a touchdown in the best football league in the world?
Yes.
And Monday night’s national championship game will show us why.
We can talk all we want about what it takes to build a roster in the NIL era, the escalation of coaching salaries and which programs are doing the best job developing talent. But at the end of the day, nearly all of it hinges on the shotgun courtship between a program and the quarterback it pulls out of the transfer portal.
Miami's Carson Beck and Indiana's Fernando Mendoza will meet in the title game on Monday night. (Getty)
Get it right and you’ve got a chance to be playing in the last game of the season like Indiana and Miami. Get it wrong and you’re talking about millions of dollars down the drain, boosters who feel like they got ripped off and coaches getting put on the hot seat.
“It’s definitely a tricky situation,” Indiana offensive coordinator Mike Shanahan said. “It happens quick.”
And it defines so much of what’s happening on the field, off the field and in courtrooms around the country.
It’s why a very specific and unorthodox legal strategy in Mississippi is being deployed to give Trinidad Chambliss the chance at one more year.
It’s why Oregon’s Dante Moore is turning down the opportunity to be a likely top-two draft pick to stay at Oregon, and why the school is willing to pay more big money for Dylan Raiola to be his understudy.
It’s why schools were desperate to get Alabama’s Ty Simpson to put his name in the portal over the last few weeks, offering millions of dollars even after he announced his intent to enter the draft where there’s a chance he won’t make as much money.
And it’s why Miami is at the center of a different storm this weekend amid Duke’s Darian Mensah putting his name in the transfer portal and breaking a contract worth $4 million next year. Despite creating all kinds of legal entanglements that will need to be resolved, it seems likely to happen one way or another because the Hurricanes need a starting quarterback next year and they’re willing to pay a lot to get one who’s proven he can play.
“Anything related to the future, we choose respectfully not to comment on because, for us, all that matters right now is this team and this opportunity,” Miami coach Mario Cristobal said Saturday. “So we'll leave it at that.”
Duke's Darian Mensah has entered the transfer portal and Miami is reportedly considered the landing spot for the talented quarterback. (Cory Knowlton/Getty Images) (Cory Knowlton/ISI Photos via Getty Images)
Not so long ago in college football, bringing in transfer quarterbacks on a year-by-year basis was the mark of an unhealthy program. Outside of Russell Wilson becoming a sensation at Wisconsin after spending four years at NC State, rent-a-quarterback situations largely did not work out very well.
“Inherently, I’m an old-school soul,” Miami offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach Shannon Dawson said. “I like to develop kids and [believe] reps within a system matter.”
But everyone here knows if Miami is going to make another run next year, it likely won’t be with a quarterback currently on the roster.
After all, this is the second year in a row both teams in the national title game have ridden one-year rentals. It could be a while before we see another national championship that recruited and developed its quarterback as a multi-year project out of high school.
In some ways, a program’s fate is as simple as this: Did you make the right bet in the transfer portal?
It’s why the eye-popping financial numbers are what they are. Though we can certainly debate whether Carson Beck’s up-and-down production was worth all those millions of dollars or whether he was as good for Miami as Cam Ward (another one-year transfer) last year, that’s not the right evaluation.
Miami is the national championship game. In a sport where the demand for good quarterbacks is greater than the supply, they have more than justified Beck’s price tag. And now they’ll do it all over again. If Mensah is the right choice, the financial and legal pain of extracting him from Duke will be worth it.
“I think it comes down a lot to that,” Miami athletic director Dan Radakovich said. “That’s a football and collective type of decision. We help kind of set the parameters in terms of what the pie is, and they divide the pie the way they need to divide it.”
Indiana is playing a similar game from Kurtis Rourke last year to Fernando Mendoza this season to, most likely, TCU transfer Josh Hoover in 2026.
Compared to Beck’s high-profile departure from Georgia, Mendoza’s announcement that he was leaving Cal a year ago generated a fraction of the fanfare. Considered a good quarterback, whose deal with Indiana landed in the reported $2 million range, Hoosiers coach Curt Cignetti may have been the only person who realized he had recruited a future Heisman Trophy winner.
“If you trust your evaluation and your history of evaluation has been successful and you have a lot of confidence in yourself and your process, you feel strong about a guy,” Cignetti said. “I felt extremely strong about Fernando. Extremely. I knew we had something.”
But on Tuesday morning, when Mendoza starts preparing to be the likely No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft, the most important question at Indiana — and maybe the only question — is going to be whether they’ve done it again with Hoover.
“It would be nice to have a guy for a few years, but when you’ve got a chance to get a guy that can play winning football, that’s been through the wars, to me it’s an easy decision,” Cignetti said. “You’ve got to win every year. Now there’s no, ‘Oh, in five years we’ll be good.’ That was a long time ago. It’s not a perfect world, college football.”
The process isn’t perfect, either. The transfer portal is only open for 15 days. Coaches and general managers have to make career-defining decisions with imperfect information. The amount of money it takes to get one of these quarterbacks raises the stakes for everyone.
At some point, if this speed dating cycle continues, Miami or Indiana is probably going to make a season-ruining mistake. It’s just how the sport works now.
“Getting to the truth a lot of times is hard,” Dawson said. “You’ve got cut through the weeds a little bit. You a blackjack player? Nothing’s 100 percent, right?
“We looked at [Beck’s] career as one of, man, this kid’s got a lot of experience. We felt like we were a really good football team and we felt like we needed somebody that’s played in some big games because we were hoping to play in some big games, and he’s been in a lot of them.”
He’s got one more Monday might. But in many ways, the biggest game of all — the one that determines who’s playing in the championship game 12 months from now — has already been played.
When you think about everything riding on the shoulders of these transfer quarterbacks and what it means to a school when they hit the way Indiana and Miami have, the $4 million salaries may not be that crazy after all.
Source: “AOL Sports”
